O U T S I D E L E F T   stay i n d e p e n d e n t

The Hissing of Herbie Hancock

How the Grammys managed to pick such a rich and complex album as River: the Joni Letters for 2007's Album of the Year is anyone's guess. I do know that Tina Turner can still kick all y'alls ass.

get the weekly Outsideleft newsletter
by Alex V. Cook, Music Editor for outsideleft.com
originally published: February, 2008
The sweet dreamlike aura the band creates is intoxicating, but you catch a glimpse heat-lightning in the clouds.
by Alex V. Cook, Music Editor for outsideleft.com
originally published: February, 2008
The sweet dreamlike aura the band creates is intoxicating, but you catch a glimpse heat-lightning in the clouds.

Herbie Hancock
River: The Joni Letters

I doubt it is too scandalous an admission that I had not heard Herbie Hancock's collection of Joni Mitchell excursions before I read that it won the Grammy as 2007 Album of the Year.  The concept has Starbucks written all over it - lessee: performer and songwriter are legendary artists both past their agreed-upon prime, Norah Jones and Corinne Bailey Rae guest on it, colon in the title. Yeah, this looks like the musical equivalent of steamed cauliflower, definitely good for you and satisfying should you order it, but it's not exactly making your mouth water when you see it on the menu.

Herbie Hancock cannot be denied, let's be clear. He has been a key player on some of the greatest records ever. When his albums veer toward cliché, it serves a peckerwood to remember that the cliché was likely based on something Hancock made up in the first place.  Joni Mitchell too.  Her great albums are singular, weird, inspiring crossroads where convention and unfettered poetry met. Albums like Blue and Court and Spark and The Hissing of Summer Lawns hold up as well today as they did when they hatched from their alien eggs decades ago.

The shocking thing about the Grammy people picking River: The Joni Letters  is not that they elected some tired-ass shit over something with more cultural currency; they do that all the time.  The shock is that they did so with such exquisite taste.  Far from being your typical slam-together of a legend with ingénues like the Ray Charles albums at the end, and far from being a milquetoast tractor-ride of jazz being idiosyncratic and running out of good ideas of its own, River is a sophisticated, complex, even daring musical statement.

"Court and Spark" eases us in with Hancock's delicate and occasionally dissonant piano slowly erupting out of the vacuum of space, only to ease into a narcotic fog when his peerless band comprised of Lionel Loueke, Wayne Shorter, Dave Holland and Vinnie Colaiuta  engulf the sonic terrain with thick lava.  Norah Jones does a good job embodying Mitchell's herky-jerk poetic style as well as playing the chanteuse, but what makes this exemplary is the slight tension in the air. The sweet dreamlike aura the band creates is intoxicating, but you catch a glimpse heat-lightning in the clouds.

The badass song here is "Edith and the Kingpin" featuring some stunning vocals from Tina Turner. Anyone with any musical knowledge can attest to the Tina's powerful voice, but I can't remember hearing a note from her since the Private Dancer era. Here, she sings with poise and gravity that you are hard-pressed to find out of anybody.  She is perfectly cast as the speakeasy doll that narrates the song, a haze of cocktail jazz with an almost subliminal funk guitar percolating through the track.

Herbie shows off his quiet fireworks in the extended intro to "Both Sides Now" and the perfect complement from his band.  Lionel Loueke does a good Bill Laswell impression on his guitar, sweeping the landscape like a lighthouse beam, leading to a slow-burn sax incantation from Shorter. A similar environment comes out of "Slow Bird." On these numbers you are experiencing well-mannered jazz of the highest quality.  None of the synthetic gloop that kills all "smooth jazz" albums no matter how well-played, this album is as organic as a vine.  As glorious as these tracks are, however, the instrumentals are eclipsed by the impact vocal numbers

Corinne Bailey Rae does a fine job on "River", in fact her girlish voice resembles that Mitchell wielded back in the day.  She does a more convincing "Joni Mitchell" than Joni Mitchell does on "Tea Leaf Prophesy" whose voice has gained a glorious patina.  Her cadence is dead-on, playing the lyrics as a counterpoint instrument, cocksure and naked at the same time.  You may have some anti-hippy bias against her, or maybe some girl that rebuked you years ago was really into her, but Joni Mitchell was then and still is kind of a badass. She's no Tina Turner, mind you, but I still wouldn't cross her.

All comers are knocked out, however, by the graveled God voice of Leonard Cohen on the album close "The Jungle Line." It reminds me of Charles Mingus' "Chill of Death" narration on his 1971 masterwork Let My Children Hear Music.   Mitchell herself collaborated with Mingus in 1979 on her cataclysmic fusion of pop and jazz and all things in between, simply titled Mingus, and Hancock was one of the many jazz titans that participated in those sessions.  The song itself was the synth 'n' tribal drumming lynchpin her 1975 The Hissing of Summer Lawns album, but with Cohen's soul-deep hipster-patois narration and Hancock's sly piano riffs, this number is the one that brings this album together.  It ties up  the jazz reverence, the pop immediacy, the persistence of Poetry into a tight bundle that one can take up on their trek into the wilderness.

Photo 1967: Syrell Sapznick from herbiehancock.com

see more stories from outsideleft's Music archive »»

Alex V. Cook
Music Editor

Alex V. Cook listens to everything and writes about most of it. His latest book, the snappily titled Louisiana Saturday Night: Looking for a Good Time in South Louisiana's Juke Joints, Honky-Tonks, and Dance Halls is an odyssey from the backwoods bars and small-town dives to the swampside dance halls and converted clapboard barns of a Louisiana Saturday Night. Don't leave Heathrow without it. His first book Darkness Racket and Twang is available from SideCartel. The full effect can be had at alex v cook.com

Outsideleft Night In
OL's Daily Playlist to Stay In For
mon.29.june, OUTSIDELEFT 100


thumb through the ancient archives:

search for something you might like...

sign up for the outsideleft weekly. a selection of new and archived stories every week. Or less.

View previous campaigns.

Busarus Saturday Morning
Get on the Bus with Joe Ambrose.
Seattle, So Much To Answer For
20 years later and Grunge still doesn't scan, but the Melvins still reign triumphant
An iPhone in Paris
You couldn't expect this mainly made on a mac mag to just ignore the iPhone, particularly as it's fashionable all over again thanks to the jailbird Paris' imprimatur
Liverpool Biennial Part 2: Silent Sound
An art event with Iain Forsyth and Jane Pollard with secret messages and music by Jason Pierce... and then the Dada milk float comes by
the system is broken
Pogus Caesar's New Billboard Project
The Back is the new front.